Chapter Seven
by: Roxanne Rene
Chloe sat on the smooth limestone bank, the wind carrying the mineral scent of the inland sea. Her denim cutoffs scraped against the rock as she watched the water shift from green to gray, its choppy surface hiding whatever lay beneath.
Behind her, the estate’s terraced gardens gave way to raw shoreline. The wind carried a distant drone that sharpened into a motorboat’s buzz, its white wake cutting the dark water before the boat itself came into view.
Walter appeared first, hair silver in the sun, one hand gripping the tow-rope while the other gestured and whooped. He skied like a man who quit impressing people years ago—wide, celebrating turns, speed for its own sake. She watched him cut across the wake and thought of Daniel, taking her to the public pool that summer, trying to give her something ordinary after their mother left.
Graham trailed him, and the gap between them looked deliberate, not accidental. Black swimming trunks, no shirt, the sun finding him at the top of a turn and throwing a single bright pane of light off his back.
Chloe studied the way his shoulders moved—swimming, she decided, or rowing, shoulders built for pulling, not pushing—and the clean taper to a waist with no give, water sheeting off him in thin silver strands each time he surfaced.
She felt her pulse in her wrists, her ears, the hollow of her collarbone; she knew she had stopped blinking; she knew Margaret sat beside her, and none of this could be hidden from a woman who read people the way Graham read contracts.
She pressed her palms flat against the limestone and felt its cold through her skin. Two years of suits, one tuxedo, one occasion when he wore nothing at all, and none of it had readied her for this: Graham on the water, black against gray-green, moving with the same exactness she knew from boardrooms.
“Do you like what you see?” Margaret asked. Her voice was light, but the question landed with precision. “Walter would have let him whoop and fall and whoop again, but I insisted on lessons. Perfect practice, or no practice at all.” She paused, letting the boat engine’s hum fill the space between them. “It produces a certain… effect, doesn’t it? That control. Though I often wonder if it leaves room for anything else.”
Chloe turned. Margaret sat beside her on the limestone, her linen shirt sleeves pushed up, her feet bare. Her cream trousers and French twist were practical, undisturbed, but a few silver strands had loosened at her temples.
“Graham always struck me as the type to refuse lessons,” Chloe said. The words were out before she could decide whether they belonged in this conversation.
Margaret’s mouth curved, and the smile reached her eyes. “You would be correct. He was stubborn. I was worse.” She watched her son carve another turn, his form perfect, his joy nothing like Walter’s. “The result is a man who performs competence well and resists experiencing it. I wonder what I cost him, insisting on his excellence.”
Chloe searched the words for the trap—a test disguised as confession. But Margaret kept watching the water, her profile showing the lines that appeared only when she smiled genuinely, as she had at breakfast when Walter’s enthusiasm overwhelmed his decorum.
“You’re not what I expected around him,” Margaret said. It wasn’t quite a question. “There’s less theater. Less… planning.”
“I didn’t realize there was theater before.”
“There’s always theater, Ms. Bennett. The interesting part is what kind, and who the audience is.” Margaret adjusted her position on the rock, a small movement that realigned everything—the kind of economy that comes from Pilates or thirty years of ballet training. “Graham mentioned you’re from Ohio. Not this end of it, I take it. The southern part, where the hills start.”
Chloe felt the familiar tightening that came with questions about her past—which facts to offer, which to keep. “Columbus area. My brother raised me after our mother left. We moved around. No one place stuck.”
“The brother who married badly.”
Married badly. The phrase landed wrong—as if Daniel’s choice of Elise had been a strategic error rather than a human one. “Elise had reasons,” Chloe said, the defense automatic even now. “Daniel was sick. She was overwhelmed. People change under pressure.”
“Do they?” Margaret’s gaze shifted from the water to Chloe’s face, her blue eyes assessing with intensity. “Or do crises simply reveal people? The generous become reckless; the selfish become obvious.”
Chloe thought of leaving Daniel’s house at twenty, two bags and a cheap coat, certain she cost too much. She thought of Elise refusing to go, and wondered which category Margaret would put her in—generous for leaving, or selfish for resenting it?
“Your son,” she said, deflecting, “seems to think people are like quarterly reports. Always room for improvement if you just adjust the variables.”
“Graham believes in control. The rest is tactics.” Margaret’s voice softened. “He gets that from both of us, I’m afraid. Walter learned to arrange the world to his liking rather than understand a person’s heart, and I—” she paused, the admission costly, “—I learned to arrange both, and called it love.”
The motorboat’s engine cut. Walter shouted something enthusiastic, indistinct. As the boat drifted toward shore, Walter waved, Graham beside him, arms folded.
“Come in!” Walter called, the words clear over the wind. “The water’s perfect, Chloe! Cool but not cruel!”
She shook her head, hoping it read as polite refusal rather than panic. Margaret was watching, and Chloe wondered what the older woman saw—fear, stubbornness, or the pride that had kept her safe for so long.
“They’ll persuade you eventually,” Margaret sighed, placing a hand on her cheek. “The Ashcroft men are terribly persistent when they want something. It’s their primary flaw and occasional virtue.”
“I don’t ski.”
“Nor do I. I observe. From dry land.” It was Walter’s line from breakfast, whether she meant it or not, and Chloe felt the echo settle where she didn’t want it. “You, though—you refuse out of something more than preference. You don’t trust the water.”
Chloe turned to look at her, trying to read criticism in her face, but found none—only attention. “I trust what I can stand on.”
“Yes. That’s what I suspected.” Margaret reached out and laid her hand on the stone beside her, her fingertips tracing its smooth, sun-warmed surface. “The limestone here is deceptive. It looks flat, then it drops away without a slope. People have stood exactly where you are now, feeling perfectly safe. They take one step too far, and the bottom just vanishes. The water doesn’t warn you—it just takes.”
The metaphor was obvious, but Chloe couldn’t resent it. Margaret spoke like someone who knew false security firsthand.
The boat drifted close enough to watch Graham step to the bow and dive without pause, surfacing already moving toward shore. Walter followed with a cannonball that drenched the interior and drew a shout from the pilot, surfacing with his silver hair flat against his skull, laughing.
Chloe watched them approach through the shifting water—Walter’s buoyant splashing, Graham’s controlled glide, each stroke pulling him closer. Then Graham stood, and the water slid off him in a single slow sheet, down his chest, over the ridged plane of his stomach, and off his thighs, sunlight catching in every bead that ran down his skin. He waded toward her, unhurried, the current parting around his hips.
She looked away. Then she looked back. Then away again. It did no good. The image was already there—water sluicing off well-oiled skin, tracing the hard lines of muscle she’d only inferred from three years of seeing him in suits. He moved toward her with the unreal precision of a magazine image made flesh, and she hated that her mouth went dry, hated more that some traitor part of her wanted to catalog every detail before he reached her.
“Walter could ski until the lake freezes over,” she muttered, ducking her head. “I think he’s powered by sheer enthusiasm rather than blood.”
“Has the cheeky Miss Chloe finally become meek?” Graham was closer than she’d calculated, amused and challenging—the look he used whenever she retreated into professional distance. Her neck went hot, the flush climbing from her collarbone to her jaw, visible against her bare skin.
She crossed her arms over her chest like a shield and pivoted on the warm limestone to meet his gaze. She kept her voice flat, a practiced neutrality she’d perfected in boardrooms. “Meek? Sweety, I prefer to call it an intelligent aversion to drowning. It’s all the rage among people who can swim.”
“Intelligent aversion? Is this what we’re calling it, now?” He stopped at the water’s edge, close enough that she could see droplets caught in his eyebrows, single beads rolling off his shoulders. “You came all this way,” he said, and there was the smile she knew—the one he used to close deals. “All that planning and you’re going to sit up there like a guest. The water’s fine. Or are you going to make me stand here alone while my father skis circles around us?”
“Maybe I’ve made a strategic choice not to feed your ego by joining in your family’s activities.”
“Maybe.” The corner of his mouth pulled up—not a full smile, more like a man who’d already read the last page. “Or maybe you’re afraid of anything that moves too fast for you to plan around.”
The accusation landed, and Chloe’s pride answered—the same pride that had carried her through years of being the girl whose mother left, the assistant who navigated boardrooms in worn shoes.
She uncrossed her arms, stood, and stepped off the rock into water that reached her ankles, then her shins, then her knees. The limestone was exactly as Margaret had described—flat-seeming, then uneven, edges that caught at her bare feet. The water was colder than she’d expected.
She stopped when it reached her thighs, her cutoffs darkening and clinging. Graham watched, unreadable, braced for her retreat.
She raised two fingers in a victory sign. “Dry land,” she said, more confidently than she felt. “Observed and survived. Your ego may now rest.”
She turned back toward the rock, toward Margaret and the dry land she meant to reclaim. Her foot landed on limestone sloping away, and she felt the wrongness before she understood it—the current, invisible, waiting for exactly this inattention.
It took her ankle first, then her calf, then her thigh. She stepped back and found no bottom where stone should have been. The water rose to her waist, her hips, and her arms flailed on their own. Her feet lifted. She heard herself make a sound that wasn’t words.
The current had her—the Lake Erie current Walter had called perfect—and she was moving from shore faster than she could think, wet fabric dragging at her arms, her legs kicking at nothing. One mortifying thought: that Graham would find her drowned, that his last sight of her would be this flailing.
Then an arm locked around her ribs from behind and pulled her up against a warm chest. She broke the surface coughing, water streaming from her nose, held against someone who was breathing hard and not letting go.
She knew the chest before she named it—the spread of fingers against her ribs, sun-warmed skin, breathing that matched hers. Graham’s other arm joined the first, and she felt every point of contact: forearm beneath her breasts, thigh pressed to hers as they kicked, his mouth near her ear making sounds that were only breath and effort.
“Chloe.” His voice rough, nothing like his usual precision. “I’ve got you. Stop fighting.”
But she couldn’t stop. The water had always had her—from the summer day an older kid shoved her into the deep end, and she sank without finding the surface. The memory was in her body more than her mind, and she thrashed against his hold until his voice cut through it: “Chloe. Listen to me. Your feet. Find my legs. Stand on my legs.”
His instruction cut through the panic. Her feet found his thighs, solid in the murk, and she pushed down. She rose, chin above water, gasps slowing to ragged pulls of air.
He didn’t let go. Her back was flush against his chest, her wet hair plastered to his cheek. She could feel his heartbeat against her shoulder blade—fast, but steady. A tremor started in her legs.
“Hold my arm,” he said, voice rough. “Don’t let go.”
She locked her fingers around his forearm, felt the muscle tighten as he began a labored sidestroke toward shore. Each pull was a battle against the current that had carried them farther out than she’d realized. Margaret stood watching from the rock. Walter swam toward them. The boat slowly reversed.
When his feet found bottom, he cautiously let her go. His hands came to her shoulders, grip firm, eyes intent. “You can’t swim.”
“I can,” she croaked. “In pools. Where I can see.”
“This isn’t a pool.” His thumbs pressed into her collarbones. “You don’t walk into a lake because I—” He broke off, ran a hand through his hair, unsteady. “That’s not how you survive.”
She looked at him—really looked—and saw the shake in his hands, the raw edge in his voice. The carefully built wall between them was gone.
He had pulled her out. She had almost drowned. The math of it was terrifying.
“Graham,” she said, the name heavy on her tongue. “I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to—”
Walter’s booming “Everyone alright?” cut through the moment. Margaret called for towels from the shore. Graham’s hands fell from her shoulders. The rawness in his eyes shuttered, replaced by familiar calm—a man regretting a lapse in control. Chloe stood in the waist-deep water, saved from the lake but drowning in a colder truth: her pride had almost cost her everything.
One thought on “The Proxy Proposal: A Contemporary Romance: Chapter Seven”